Bingham Award

Body

Each Spring the Philosophy Department awards the Bingham Prize to a deserving undergraduate. This award is designed to recognize and award undergraduate excellence in Philosophy. The Philosophy Department will present the prize of $750 and an engraved medal to the winner.

Qualifications for Submissions

  • You must have taken an undergraduate philosophy course at OSU during the current school year or during spring term of the previous year.
  • You must have written the essay since spring break the previous year.
  • You must have your essay endorsed by a faculty member or graduate teaching associate in the Philosophy Department. For that purpose please use the following:

Download a

File


Deadline for Submission: Monday, March 16, 2020 - 4:00 p.m.

Length: maximum page length for Bingham submissions is 20 pages
(double spaced, no smaller than 12-pt type, with reasonable margins.)

NOTE: If you are submitting a chapter from an honors thesis, please be sure to rework it as a free-standing paper.

Submission Instructions

  1. Fill out the nomination form and have your faculty/TA supporter sign it. Have a hard copy of the form delivered to Michelle Brown, Department of Philosophy, 350 University Hall, no later than the advertised deadline.
  2. To permit a blind review, prepare an electronic manuscript of the paper, in which your name does not appear anywhere. The full title of the paper should appear at the top of the first page (i.e., there is no title page) Save this manuscript as a .doc or .pdf file. When you create the file, be sure that the author-box in the information on the file is left blank. Name the file ‘Bingham XX’, when ‘XX’ is the first two words of the title of your paper.
  3. By the advertised deadline, email this manuscript to Michelle Brown at (brown.930@osu.edu).
  4. In the subject line of the email message write ‘a Bingham submission’.
  5. In the body of the message write:
    1. 'The title of the paper hereby submitted to the Bingham Competition: XXX', when 'XXX' is replaced by the full title that is also at the top of your manuscript, and
    2. 'Author: YYY', when 'YYY' is replaced by your name

REMEMBER TO ATTACH THE MANUSCRIPT (prepared for blind review)

Submissions received after the advertised deadline will be invalid and will not enter the competition. You will receive an acknowledgement within one business day of your submission.

A Brief History

William E. Bingham was born in England in 1884. He was compelled to terminate his formal education at the age of 14, and five years later he emigrated to Canada, where he assiduously prepared himself for enrollment in college. He studied philosophy at Ohio State University from 1914 to 1916 and upon graduation proceeded to Cornell University to pursue a graduate degree. However, in April 1917, with the threat of world war looming on the horizon, William Bingham enlisted in the United States Navy and a year later graduated from Annapolis as an ensign. In November of 1918 he married. Within a month after returning to duty he drowned when a boatload of sailors on patrol near Gibraltar capsized in heavy seas. His remains are located in the Arlington National Cemetery.

The post-war philosophy students here at Ohio State reacted to the untimely death of William Bingham first by producing a memorial issue of their yearbook, The Thinker, and then by deciding to create a memorial award to commemorate his bravery and memory. By 1921 a medal was commissioned by a famous French medalist and for a number of years this was offered as the award. In 1936 there was no medal available for the recipient, and during the Second World War the dies were lost. In 1944 an again in 1958, unsuccessful efforts were made to replace the cast. It appears that during some of this time the department awarded a picture of the medal to the winners of the prize. In addition, books were frequently awarded as well, and in 1950 an award of $25 was offered for the purchase of books. In the 1960's, a new medal was commissioned by the department, but it was not considered as attractive as the original. Finally, in 1981, the Department secured one of the original medals and had a new mold for this medal made. Current winners receive a copy of the original medal (shown below) and a cash prize of $500.00. The undergraduate scholar is then invited to present the winning paper to the faculty and fellow students at an award ceremony.

See the nomination form for further requirements and the submission deadline. Contact the Department for more information concerning the contest.

Front of Bingham MedalBack of Bingham Medal

Note: While there have been some years in which a Bingham Medal was not awarded, we know that the following list has significant omissions. We regret these omissions and ask your assistance in correcting them. If you, or someone you know, received a Bingham Medal that is not indicated below, or if you can help us with the titles of winning papers where they are missing, please contact Michelle Brown.

 
Year Bingham Winner Paper title
2019  Miranda McKinney

Joseph Glandorf

“Cursed to be Time Travelers: Time and Personal Identity in Book XI of the Confessions of St. Augustine"

"Descartes and Gassendi on Meditation Two"

2018 Garrett Patterson "Avoiding a Collective Action Objection to Norm-Expressivism"
2017 Zhiyuan Li Not "Never Better to Have Been": The Position of Moderate Anti-Natalism
2016 Katelyn Aberl "Embracing Counterintuitiveness in Haslanger's View for Feminist Action"
2016 Troy Seagraves "Boghossian and Rule-Circularity"
2015 Brad Griggs “Hume on Practical Reason: How Skeptical Is He?”
2014 Brandon Sadowsky “Irrational Blame: A Problem for Scanlon”
2013 Not Awarded Not Awarded
2012 Kirun K. Sankaran "Inferentialism and Indeterminacy: Kripke, Brandom and Wilson"
2011 Dan Giglio “The Price of Fictional Realism”
2011 Gabbrielle M. Johnson “Reference Magnetism and Macro-Naturalism”
2010 James Kinkaid "Nietzche, The Scientific Spiritualist"
2010 Benjamin W. Priest "Towards Unifying Logical Harmony"
2009 Timothy J. Leffel "Should an Intuitionist Accept Church's Thesis?"
2008 John Wasserman "On Death"
2007 Not Awarded Not Awarded
2006 Michael Ondrick "The Moral Status of Lies with Regard to Consequentialism and Deontology -- or -- Chuck Meets an Untimely Demise Once Again"
2005 Neil Lall "Montague's Justice-Based Self-Defense Against Innocent Attackers"
2004 Whitney Gegg-Harrison "An Examination of Kripke's "A Puzzle About Belief"
2003 Andy Chupick "Justification and Religious Belief: God and the Given"
2002 Jason Allan Miller "The Metaphysical Status of Modal Property Attributions"
2001 Benjamin Beebe "Between Gauthier and the Sensible Knave: A Possible Reconciliation"
2000 John Glass "Kant and the Transcendental Unity of Apperception"
1999 Mary Madia "Objections to the Nature of Railton's Evaluative Facts"
1998 Elizabeth Tropman "Externalism, Vernacular Explanation and Explanatory Relevance"
1997 Stephanie Partridge "God Endures"
1995 Steven Blatti "Locke on Extension in Atoms"
1994 Natalie Slavens "Maimonides on Creation"
1993 James Okapal "Morals By Accident"
1991 John Sarefield "Berkeley and the Problem of Other Minds"
1990 Maria Dawn Senediar "Lawyers for Indigents"
1989 Todd Lekan "Dostoevsky and Sartre on Freedom"
1987 Scott Davison "Could God Foreknow Human Free Actions?"
1986 Barry Wacksman "Some Old Problems for the New Materialism"
1985 Jonathan Kandell  
1984 Mark Svede  
1982 Mark Lance "Reference Without Causation"
1981 Kenneth Rose "Theoria: Participatory Metaphysics"
1980 Mark Lance "Observation Sentences and Aesthetic Perception"
1979 Nancy Peters
Christopher Wilson
"On Austin and the Star-speck"
"Some Relevant Reflections on Goldman's Analysis of Knowledge"
1968 Nancy Weber  
1967 Jim Blue  
1966 Alexander Mosley  
1965 Jeffrey Parker  
1964 Lyle Angene  
1963 James Child  
1946 George Little Williams  
1939 Eugene P. Drucker  
1935 Raymond Mikesell  
1934 Nathan Grundstein  
1932 Francis McPeak  
1931 Mary Sabine  
1930 Robert Gunning  
1929 J. B. Rieker, Jr.  
1928 Thomal A Faulhaber "Justice"
1924 Kenneth Smoke  
1923 Florence Everhard "Evolutionism and Ethics"
1922 Eugene Derby  

[pdf] — Some links on this page are to PDF files requiring the use of Adobe Reader. If you need these files in a more accessible format, please contact brown.930@osu.edu.